Commenting on the Strength of Opposition to the Proposed Closure of Menzieshill High School

Laurie Bidwell , Labour's Education Spokesperson in Dundee

27 January 2015

The mounting number of supporters for the 'Stop the Closure of Menzieshill High School' online petition is another indicator that there is growing resistance to the proposed closure of the school.

The consultation meeting at the school last Thursday was attended by a 200+ group of parents, carers and pupils who overwhelmingly were also not convinced by the Education Director's case for the closure of the school.


What also emerged from that meeting and the comments made by the supporters of the petition is that Menzieshill High school is held in high esteem by pupils and former pupils.


Its location at the heart of the Lochee ward mean that it is a real 'community school' serving its pupils and recreational groups that use its extensive sports facilities.


The relative smallness of the current school roll seems to be one of the features that contributes to it being a good place to learn which is less daunting for pupils coming up from Primary.


On the other hand the location and size of Harris Academy, with a projected school roll almost three times the size of Menzieshill High School are real put offs.


I hope the SNP group of City Councillors, who have backed the proposal to shut the school, are listening.


The petition is at :


27 January 2015

In 100 days Scotland can help end Tory rule across the UK.

The opinion polls show that this general election is neck and neck between Labour and the Tories.

It looks like the closest election for decades and Scotland can decide whether David Cameron stays or goes.

Scotland is changing, and Scottish Labour is changing with it.

It’s a fresh start for Scottish Labour and the path to a better nation runs through May 7th and getting the Tories out.

Only the biggest party after the general election can form a government.

In the referendum whether you were Yes or whether you were No, most Scots know it's time for the Tories to go.

Only Labour is big enough and strong enough to defeat David Cameron.

Scotland can protest against the Tories by voting for any party but only Labour can replace them.

A vote for the SNP risks five more years of the Tories, five more years of misery on our most vulnerable, and five more years of wasted opportunities for our young people.

A Labour government will change Scotland, and the whole UK, for the better.

We will tax the bonuses of bankers in London to guarantee a job for every young person in Scotland.

We will use a UK-wide Mansion Tax on properties worth over £2 million to deliver better funding for our NHS.

Labour believes those who can afford to pay a bit more to support our schools and hospitals should, that is why we would introduce a 50p top rate of tax on the highest earners.

We will make work pay, by increasing the minimum wage and banning exploitative zero hour contracts, and we’ll encourage more employers to pay better, with tax incentives to pay the living wage.

In 100 days we can choose progress over protest by sending Scottish Labour MPs to help form a UK Labour government.

Download this news release (PDF format)

The V&A Dundee : Way Forward Agreed  >>>

View the Scottish Labour video >>>

Download a copy of Jim Murphy's Five Point Plan for Dundee (PDF)


Huge Increase in cost of V&A Dundee

Comment by

Kevin Keenan , Labour Group Leader on Dundee City Council  >>>

Richard McCready, Labour Group Spokesperson on Culture on Dundee City Council >>>

Jenny Marra MSP >>>

A video message for 2015 from  Jim Murphy, Leader of the Scottish Labour Party, and Kezia Dugdale, Deputy Leader >>.




Ed Miliband's New Year Message : The Chance To Change Direction



 Jim Murphy, Leader of the Scottish Labour Party


View the larger screen version of this video >>>

Download a copy of Jim Murphy's speech >>>



Kezia Dugdale and Jim Murphy, leader and Deputy Leader of the Scottish Labour Party ( view larger-sized image >>>)




Jim Murphy and Kezia Dugdale on his speech about Clause 4


Ed Miliband: I'm fighting for a fairer, more just Britain